Image Credit : https://edition.cnn.com/travel/article/k2-busiest-climbing-season-ever-intl-hnk/index.html
Have you ever wondered why Annapurna is considered the killer mountain even when there are other peaks higher in altitudes? Do you wish to know which mountain is more dangerous, Mount K2 or Mount Annapurna? Read this article to learn everything in detail about Mount. Annapurna and Mount. K2.
The two remarkable peaks in the world, Mt. Annapurna and Mt. K2 are admired by climbers due to their challenging landscape and breathtaking beauty. Despite their intimidating reputation, both peaks attract climbers from all around the world. Each year, several expeditions are set out to tackle their icy slopes. It is because the climbers believe scaling K2 or Mount Annapurna is the ultimate test of mountaineering and endurance. With a rich history of expeditions and conquests, both the mountains continue to leave behind numerous stories of success and failure.
Get Free Quotes, Compare and Save on Your Ultimate Nepal Trekking Experience
Effortlessly connect with multiple Nepal trek providers to find the perfect adventure at the best price.
Mount Annapurna
Image Credit : https://www.nepaltrekkinginhimalaya.com/package/mount-annapurna-iv-expedition
Nestled in the heart of the majestic Himalayas, Mount Annapurna is a massif consisting of several peaks including Annapurna I. Standing tall at an elevation of 8091 meters, Mount Annapurna is also entitled as the killer mountain. Despite being prominent for its staggering vistas and magnificent topography, this iconic giant of the mountaineering world is full of difficulties and deadly risks.
Annapurna I was first climbed in 1950 by a French expedition team. Led by Maurice Herzog, the expedition included three other names Lionel Terray, Gaston Rebuffat, and Marcel Ichac. They made it to the summit of Annapurna on June 3, 1950. Since then, 365 people have successfully made it to the top of the world’s deadliest mountain and there have been 72 recorded deaths to this date.
Mount K2
Image Credit :https://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-adventure/climbing/k2-first-winter-ascent/
Mount K2, also known as Chhogori or Qogir, the second-highest mountain in the world lies in the Karakoram Mountain range on the Pakistan-China border. It got its unusually short name in 1852. 2 for being the second highest in the world and K refers to the Karakoram Range it resides in. Standing at an awe-inspiring height of 8611 meters, Mount K2 is eminent for its treacherous climb and unparalleled beauty.
Given the name Savage Mountain for its extreme difficulty, Mount K2 has never been climbed during the winter. The first expedition to K2 was done in 1982 by a German team however they only managed to reach 4691 meters. Later in 1902, another attempt was done to climb K2, but they also only managed to reach a height of 6525 meters after five ventures.
It was only after 1954, an Italian expedition led by Ardito Desio reached the top of the mountain. Since that date, Wanda Rutkiewicz of Poland marked herself as the first-ever woman to have climbed Mount K2. The list was lengthened by Carlos Soria Fontan of Spain as the oldest woman reaching the peak at the age of 65 in 2004.
According to the reports, as of 2022, only 377 people have successfully summited K2, and 91 have lost their lives in between.
Get Free Quotes, Compare and Save on Your Ultimate Nepal Trekking Experience
Effortlessly connect with multiple Nepal trek providers to find the perfect adventure at the best price.
Annapurna Vs K2: Which is More Dangerous?
Both Annapurna and K2 are one of the toughest mountains when it comes to climbing. However, even though the terrain of K2 is highly challenging and steeper than Annapurna, the 10th highest mountain in the world is still considered one of the most dangerous.
So, what makes Annapurna actually the most vicious? It is because of the notoriously unpredictable weather conditions of the Annapurna range that changes rapidly even during the peak climbing seasons. The occurrence of high winds, snowstorms, and deadly avalanches along with steep terrain and unstable snowpack is what makes the mountain most deadly.
Additionally, despite Mountain K2 is considered technically challenging; Annapurna has several sections that are reported to be extremely difficult to navigate. One of the most dangerous sections is the Annapurna massif with a steep exposed ridge having significant rock fall hazard.
Another factor making Annapurna life-threatening is altitude sickness. It might sound funny but you are more likely to undergo altitude sickness when climbing Annapurna compared to any other mountain owing to altitude. The elevation of Annapurna can pose significant health risks to climbers which can be fatal if not treated on time. Also because Annapurna lies in a highly remote area and thus it’s difficult to get immediate health-related aid in cases of emergency.
Fatality Rates of Annapurna and K2
The two most iconic mountains in the world, Mount Annapurna and K2 are best known for their unique beauty, environmental characteristics, and cultural significance. However, beyond their alluring charm, these mountains have the worst records of human deaths.
As of 2022, Annapurna is divulged to have a fatality rate of 32%, which is the highest of any eight-thousanders. On the other hand, the fatality rate for Mount K2 is known to be 25% and is said to be drastically decreasing over the years.
Annapurna Vs K2: The Risk Involved in Climbing Each Mountain
Talking about Annapurna Vs K2, the two most challenging mountains in the world, the risks associated with both of them are unique and significant. For decades, these towering peaks have taken lives of some experienced climbers while impeding countless more to challenge and push their limits.
Having the reputation as the world’s deadliest mountain, Mount Annapurna is known to have the biggest risks of crevasses, especially on its north face. Crevasses are the deep cracks found in the ice that are tough to see posing serious threats to climbers. Likewise, other associated risks with climbing Annapurna can be avalanches, rock falls, unpredictable weather, high altitudes, and altitude sickness.
In a comparable manner, Mount K2 is considered to be the riskiest because of the avalanches and rock falls. The route to K2 passes through a narrow section that is famed for avalanches. There are records of climbers being killed at the very section in 2008. Moreover, steep ice slopes, heavy snowfall, and high winds add more risks to the incredible journey.
Annapurna Vs K2: Climate and Weather Conditions of Both Mountains
The two highest peaks in the world are renowned for their extreme and frequently changing weather conditions. Both these mountains witness some differences in weather and climate patterns being located in two different locations in the world.
Situated in the Himalayas of Nepal, Mount Annapurna offers you with predominantly alpine climate. The mountain mainly experiences four different seasons, with the winter months being extremely cold and dry. The summers in the Annapurna region are said to be warm and wet. Being rich in diverse flora and fauna, autumn and spring are known to be beautiful seasons to summit the mountain. Not only the skies are blue but also the trails are covered with vibrant shades of pink and red rhododendron flowers.
The average temperature of Annapurna ranges from 15-20˚C during the summer months whereas the winters are known to have a temperature of 5-10˚C at lower altitudes. But, as the elevation exceeds, the temperature drops are severe making the climate harder to survive.
On the other hand, Mount K2 located in the Karakoram Range in Pakistan has a harsh subarctic climate. With long cold winters and short cool summers, the temperature drop is highly deadly during the winter season. This region is known for extreme temperatures and low precipitation. The average temperature here during the summer months is known to be around 10-15˚C while the winters drop to -30 and even lower.
Are you interested in trekking in the Annapurna region? Discover here the best Annapurna base camp trekking companies in Nepal.
Annapurna Vs K2: Equipment and Gears Required for Climbing
Climbing Mt. Annapurna and Mt. K2 is surely not for faint hearts and nonprepared climbers. Both these ascend are significant undertakings that require you to have specialized gears and equipment along with strong physical and mental endurance.
You should carry high-altitude mountaineering clothing which are not only warm but also waterproof and breathable for Annapurna.
Similarly, a durable and sturdy tent that is lightweight and can withstand strong winds and heavy snowfall should not be missed. In addition to that, a supreme sleeping bag is extremely important for both the mountains.
A high-quality backpack is another essential piece of gear that should be substantial enough to support harsh weather conditions and longer climbs. The backpacks should be large enough to store all the equipment without hindering the balance of climbers while moving upwards. Moreover, you will also need a variety of technical equipment like ropes, harnesses, crampons, helmets, and ice axes to manage the steep terrain and protect yourself in case of falls.
Explore the beauty of the Annapurna region with some highly experienced trekking operators. Read our article Best trekking companies for Annapurna and plan your ultimate adventure in the Himalayas today.
Annapurna and K2: Why do People still climb them?
Despite the high level of risk associated with both mountains, people still summit Annapurna as well as K2 each year. The reasons can vary depending on their preferences however some beautiful motivations drive climbers to carry on with the challenging peaks.
One of the most common reasons why so many people try to ascend to Annapurna as well as K2 is the sense of accomplishment and personal achievement of exploring such dangerous feats. It helps adventure lovers to feel alive from within and reconnect with nature and the outdoors. Additionally, most people are willing to dive into nature and wish to explore some of the remote and wild places to get away from the hassles of everyday life.
Annapurna and K2 both are popularly known for their stunning landscapes and breathtaking natural beauty. While Annapurna let you explore the deep gorges, lush forests, serene rivers, and high-altitude plateaus. K2 on the other hand is famously known for dramatic icefalls, towering peaks, and remote landscapes.
FAQs
Annapurna being the tenth highest in the world, is still the most challenging mountain with several sections said to be more difficult than K2 and Everest.
No, Mount Annapurna and K2 are two different peaks. While Annapurna I is the 10th highest mountain located in Nepal, K2 is the 2nd highest peak after Everest located in Pakistan.
Annapurna the mountain located in the north-central part of Nepal is considered one of the deadliest mountains in the world because of a variety of reasons. It is also known as the one most difficult to climb.
Yes, K2 even being the second highest in the world while Everest is on top of the list, is considered more dangerous than Everest, especially during the winter.
Climbing K2 without prior experience is not recommended because of the technical difficulty. You need to at least climb one eight thousander before summiting Mount K2.
Even though there are successful attempts at climbing K2 without supplemental oxygen but you need to be highly experienced to do so. In all other cases, even though it’s possible, it is not recommended to climb K2 without oxygen because of the high altitude sickness.